I remember once having a discussion with a friend about one of my favorite subjects, The Beatles. Been a Beatle freak all my life, I have, and this year being their 50th anniversary, wanted to get some thoughts down.
My friend was saying that he thought Paul was a little more talented than John. Now everyone is entitled to their own opinion, this is no communist state here, but I have to clear this up. This is hogwash. I'm not just saying this because I'm a John guy, but it's impossible to compare the two. Sure they churned out most of the Beatles' catalog together, but their writing and musical styles were miles apart. This is what made them a good partnership; they complemented each other.
You can say that Paul had a knack for a melody. No argument here. But so did John. Listen to "This Boy", "If I Fell", "Across the Universe", "Yes It Is" "And Your Bird Can Sing", "No Reply", "Because". All John songs, and all stunningly beautiful melodies.
John's songs were more gutteral, more viceral, and at times, more desperate. Paul's love songs could get a woman's panties around her ankles, but John's love songs broke your heart, and made you think.
You can say Paul is a better singer. Listen to "Baby It's You", "Eight Days a Week", "Nowhere Man", the disturbingly haunting vocal on "A Day In The Life", not to mention the lead and backing vocals on "Rain". All sung by John with flawless execution.
I'm not down on Paul. I love his songs just as much as John's, but to say one is more talented than the other is missing the point. They were a major talent together, and accented each other's strengths, and built on each other's weaknesses. There had never been a partnership like this one, and there never will be again. Happy Anniversary, guys. Rock on.
Ever wonder what it would be like to be stuck on a desert island? Not like on "Lost", where there's a thousand people around, and outrageous happenings happening. More like a Tom Hanks situation in "Cast Away". Completely alone, nothing with you. Except, of course, your favorite cds of all time! The ones you've always loved for years and can't imagine not having in your collection. How would you hear them, stuck on a desert island and all? You're resourceful. You'll think of something. Which ones would you bring? Me? Glad you asked.
1. Travelling Wilburys "Vol. 1" 1988 George Harrison, Bob Dylan, Roy Orbison, Jeff Lynne, and Tom Petty. The best work any of these guys had done to date. And they did it together. Get this one if you don't have it.
2. Blue Angel "Blue Angel" 1980 Cyndi Lauper's band before becoming famous. Great album. Full of 60's inspired romps played with high energy and wicked precision. Lauper's vocals rival any solo effort, except on "Everybody's Got An Angel", which she wails woefully off key. Other than that, solid performances from both her and the band.
3. Donnie Iris "Back On The Streets" 1981 Donnie Iris had a small radio hit in 1969 with a band called The Jaggerz. The song was "The Rapper". This is his first solo effort and was well worth the wait. Great melodies, great rock grooves, layer upon layer of vocals and guitars to create an 80's "wall of sound". This is the album that yielded "Ah! Leah".
4. The Beatles "Abbey Road" 1969 I am a Beatle freak, so any of their albums would do, but this is one of my favorites. They knew they wanted to break up, but wanted to do one more album before calling it quits. The result is sheer perfection. Lovingly crafted and produced, it is a fine farewell from the greatest band of all time.
5. The Osmonds "The Plan" 1973 Stop laughing. This was their "Sgt. Pepper", and they managed to pull it off. Concieved as a love letter to God, it is insightful, well written and well played
.6. "The Music Man" 1962 Motion Picture Soundtrack Okay, this you can laugh at, and I won't care. I love the musical trickery that courses through this one. Contains the world's very first rap song. And, I'm sorry, but in the movie, Shirley Jones is too hot for words.
7. Squeeze "East Side Story" 1981 They wanted Paul McCartney to produce this, and it shows. They had ditched their electronic sound by this time, and went with Beatle sounding songs that work remarkably well. Paul didn't produce. Instead they had Elvis Costello, with two tracks produced by Nick Lowe and Dave Edmunds. The cream of the second British invasion.
8. Squeeze "Cool For Cats" 1979 Two albums previous, it has some of the electronic sound, but mostly just good pop. It was their second album, with material intended for their first. When they showed up to record the first album, the producer didn't like any of the songs they brought with them, so he sent them away to write new stuff. Thank God they saved the original stuff. It is severley infectious music.
9. Barenaked Ladies "Gordon" 1992 Again, any of these guys' cds would do, but this one is special. Their debut album, you can hardly believe they were in their early 20's when this one was done. All acoustic, they run the gambit of musical styles and moods through the songs here. Probably one of the best albums I've ever heard.
10. Heart "Greatest Hits/Live" 1980 The only reason I brought this one was for the cover of Aaron Neville's "Tell It Like It Is". If Annie's vocals don't give you goose bumps, you ain't alive.
I'm sure there's more I'm forgetting, but that's a good start. These are the cds that I will never get sick of. How about you? What would you bring? If you're coming, bring me a freakin' cd player, would ya?